NPS Vatsalya vs Sukanya Samriddhi : Comprehensive Guide for a 15-Year Investment Plan
NPS Vatsalya vs Sukanya Samriddhi : When it comes to securing the financial future of your child, selecting the right investment plan is a critical decision. Among the various government-backed schemes available, two popular options are the NPS Vatsalya and the Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY). Both schemes have their unique features, objectives, and benefits, but parents are often left confused about which scheme will provide better returns in the long run, especially over a 15-year investment horizon.
Table of Contents
In this detailed comparison, we will break down both schemes, analyze their returns, and assess their suitability based on various factors, including risk tolerance, investment tenure, and long-term goals. While the NPS Vatsalya is a relatively new market-linked scheme, the Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana has been a popular debt-oriented investment plan specifically designed for the welfare of girl children. We will delve into the specific features, pros, and cons of each scheme to help you make an informed decision.
1. Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY): Securing the Future for Girls
The Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana was launched as part of the government’s ‘Beti Bachao Beti Padhao’ campaign, aimed at promoting the education and financial security of the girl child.
Buy Now : Investment & Credit Course
It is one of the most popular long-term savings schemes available for Indian parents who have a daughter below the age of 10.
Key Features of SSY:
- Eligibility: Available only for parents with a girl child under 10 years of age.
- Interest Rate: The interest rate for SSY is fixed by the government and is subject to periodic revision. As of now, the interest rate is around 8.2% per annum.
- Tenure: The scheme matures after 21 years from the date of opening the account. However, contributions can be made only for the first 15 years, after which the account continues to earn interest till maturity.
- Tax Benefits: Contributions made to SSY are eligible for tax deduction under Section 80C of the Income Tax Act, up to a maximum of ₹1.5 lakh per year. Additionally, the interest earned and the maturity amount are tax-free.
- Deposit Limits: The minimum annual contribution is ₹250, while the maximum contribution allowed in a year is ₹1.5 lakh.
- Partial Withdrawal: Up to 50% of the balance can be withdrawn after the girl turns 18 for educational or marriage expenses.
Returns from SSY:
The SSY is considered a safe and secure investment option since it is a government-backed scheme. The returns are linked to the interest rate, which is generally higher than other fixed-income products like fixed deposits or Public Provident Fund (PPF). Over a 15-year period, if a parent invests ₹10,000 per month, the total investment amount would be ₹18 lakhs. Based on an interest rate of 8.2%, the corpus at the end of 15 years would be approximately ₹34,56,412.
Moreover, since the scheme continues for an additional six years without any further deposit, the amount will continue to grow, resulting in a higher corpus at maturity, which occurs after 21 years.
2. NPS Vatsalya: A Market-Linked Investment for Children’s Future
The NPS Vatsalya scheme was introduced with the objective of providing parents with a long-term investment option that could help them build a corpus for their child’s future needs, such as higher education, marriage, or even retirement planning. Unlike SSY, the NPS Vatsalya is a market-linked scheme, meaning the returns are not guaranteed and depend on the performance of the underlying investments, which may include a mix of equity and debt instruments.
Key Features of NPS Vatsalya:
- Eligibility: Available for all children irrespective of gender.
- Returns: NPS Vatsalya offers market-linked returns, typically in the range of 10-12% per annum. These returns are higher compared to traditional fixed-income schemes but come with an element of risk due to exposure to equity markets.
- Investment Tenure: The NPS Vatsalya scheme allows parents to invest for their child until they turn 18. After that, the account is converted into a regular NPS account, allowing the child to continue investing for their retirement.
- Tax Benefits: Contributions to NPS are eligible for tax deductions under Section 80C and Section 80CCD of the Income Tax Act. Additionally, upon maturity, a portion of the corpus can be withdrawn tax-free.
- Flexibility: Parents can choose between different investment options, including a mix of equity, corporate bonds, and government securities, allowing them to customize the portfolio based on their risk appetite.
- Partial Withdrawal: Similar to the regular NPS scheme, partial withdrawals are allowed for specific needs such as higher education or marriage.
Returns from NPS Vatsalya:
Since NPS Vatsalya is a market-linked scheme, the returns can vary depending on the performance of the underlying investments. Assuming an average annual return of 12%, if a parent invests ₹10,000 per month for 15 years, the total investment amount would be ₹18 lakhs, similar to SSY. However, due to the higher return potential, the corpus at the end of 15 years would be approximately ₹50,45,760.
Also Read : NPS – Invest 166 Rs Daily | Get 1 Lakh Rupees Pension Monthly
This significant difference in returns is due to the power of compounding and the higher average return offered by equity-linked investments. However, it’s important to note that while NPS Vatsalya offers higher returns, it also comes with higher risk, especially in times of market volatility.
Comparing Returns for a 15-Year Investment:
Let’s break down the numbers for a clearer comparison between NPS Vatsalya and SSY based on an investment of ₹10,000 per month over 15 years:
| Scheme | Total Investment | Interest/Return Rate | Corpus After 15 Years |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY) | ₹18 lakhs | 8.2% per annum | ₹34,56,412 |
| NPS Vatsalya | ₹18 lakhs | 10-12% per annum | ₹50,45,760 |
From the table, it’s clear that NPS Vatsalya has the potential to generate a significantly higher corpus at the end of 15 years. However, parents need to consider their risk appetite before opting for NPS Vatsalya, as it is a market-linked product and returns are not guaranteed. In contrast, SSY offers a more stable and predictable return, making it a safer option for conservative investors.
Additional Factors to Consider:
Investment Objective:
- SSY: If the primary goal is the financial security of a girl child for education or marriage, SSY is a well-suited option, given its fixed returns and government backing.
- NPS Vatsalya: If the goal is long-term wealth accumulation for retirement or higher education, and if the parent is comfortable with market risks, NPS Vatsalya could be a better choice due to its higher return potential.
Taxation:
Both SSY and NPS Vatsalya offer tax benefits under Section 80C. However, SSY provides an added advantage as the interest earned and the maturity amount are completely tax-free. In contrast, in NPS, only a portion of the maturity amount can be withdrawn tax-free, with the remaining amount used to purchase an annuity that is taxable.
Liquidity:
SSY has more restrictions in terms of liquidity, as partial withdrawals are only allowed after the child turns 18 and can only be used for specific purposes like education or marriage. NPS Vatsalya, on the other hand, offers more flexibility in terms of partial withdrawals.
NPS Vatsalya vs Sukanya Samriddhi – Conclusion:
While both schemes have their advantages, the decision between NPS Vatsalya and Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana boils down to your risk tolerance, investment goals, and the specific financial needs of your child.
- If you prefer a low-risk, stable investment option with guaranteed returns and are specifically investing for a girl child, SSY is a safer bet.
- If you are open to higher risk for potentially higher returns and want flexibility in investment for both boys and girls, along with the possibility of using the corpus for long-term financial goals like retirement, NPS Vatsalya might offer better value over a 15-year horizon.
In conclusion, parents should carefully assess their financial situation and long-term goals before deciding which scheme to opt for. Both SSY and NPS Vatsalya serve different purposes, and selecting the right one depends on whether you prioritize guaranteed returns or higher growth potential.
Keywords : NPS Vatsalya vs Sukanya Samriddhi – NPS Vatsalya vs Sukanya Samriddhi 2024 – NPS Vatsalya vs Sukanya Samriddhi 2025
